PRO14: Teams up for Edinburgh v Ulster

Published Categorised as 2019-20, Edinburgh Rugby, PRO14, Provincial Rugby Men, Ulster Rugby Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

The teams are out for Ulster’s crunch Guinness PRO14 semi final match against Edinburgh.

Ulster are boosted by the inclusions of Jacob Stockdale, Alan O’Connor, Stuart McCloskey and Jordi Murphy who were doubts after the Leinster match.

Eric O’Sullivan and Tom O’Toole start alongside Rob Herring in the front row. Alan O’Connor went off early last week but is named to start alongside Sam Carter in the second row. Matthew Rea resumes at six with Jordi Murphy and Marcell Coetzee completing the back row trio.

Billy Burns returns to the starting line up alongside John Cooney at half back. McCloskey’s inclusion is a huge boost and he is joined by James Hume in the centres. There’s no room for Craig Gilroy or Matt Faddes on the wings with Rob Lyttle and Louis Ludik occupying those spots. Stockdale starts at 15 for the third match in a row.

With O’Sullivan and O’Toole named as props, we’ll see Ulster play off nine from the ruck with the receiving player popping to someone in more space. O’Sullivan is a great exponent of this play and Ulster have had some success with it in the past.

Richard Cockerill’s Edinburgh side have fared better than Ulster since the restart of the competition recording a win in their opening match against Glasgow Warriors. Although they were flat and lost out on Friday, Cockerill had made some changes with this week in mind.

Despite the former Leicester Tigers’ man being very complimentary towards McFarland’s Ulster in the build up to this match and insisting the Irish side are favourites, I cannot share his opinion. I agree with him that there is pressure on Ulster to win especially comparing the budgets between the sides and that they’ve not reached a PRO14 final since 2013 – a travesty considering the quality of players in Belfast over the last number of seasons.

Cockerill took the reigns in the Scottish capital at the start of the 2017-18 season with Edinburgh finishing in ninth position, above only Benetton Treviso, Newport Gwent Dragons and Zebre. His first season saw him pip Ulster to the final knockout spot in the newly restructured PRO14 while last season saw a European run which controversially ended with a quarter loss to Munster at Murrayfield.

Blair Kinghorn, Duhan van der Merwe, Jaco van der Walt and Darcy Graham grab the headlines in the back line while up front Bill Mata is an exciting number eight along with scavengers Hamish Watson and Magnus Bradbury in the back row and Stuart McInally, Rory Sutherland and Grant Gilchrist in the front five. They have Pierre Schoeman coming off the bench who is a great scrummager and useful in the loose.

This represents a great chance for Ulster to book their first final appearance since 2013. They don’t have the mental baggage playing against Edinburgh that they would have against Munster or Leinster and have a decent record against sides that Cockerill has coached.

Last season Ulster went to Murrayfield needing a win to wrap up second place. The ball carriers made good yards and plus one pop passes kept the defence on the back foot. While Ulster can be dealt with by keeping Coetzee and McCloskey quiet, the same can be said for Edinburgh and Mata, restricting his ability to offload will prevent Edinburgh making bursts and recycling the ball to their clinical back line.

Discipline has to be a lot better this week. While the penalty count only reached ten against Leinster – quite low compared to other teams – a lot of them were preventable. It’s not possible for Ulster to continuously allow sides an early lead through stupid mistakes if they want to challenge for silverware.

The FRU predicts: I’ve Edinburgh as favourites for this match but would be slightly more confident than if they were up against Munster or Leinster. However I think Ulster will come up short against a well drilled Edinburgh side.

EdinburghUlster
Blair Kinghorn15Jacob Stockdale
Darcy Graham14Louis Ludik
Mark Bennett13James Hume
Chris Dean12Stuart McCloskey
Duhan van der Merwe11Rob Lyttle
Jaco van der Walt10Billy Burns
Nic Groom9John Cooney
Rory Sutherland1Eric O’Sullivan
Stuart McInally2Rob Herring
WP Nel3Tom O’Toole
Ben Toolis4Alan O’Connor
Grant Gilchrist5Sam Carter
Magnus Bradbury6Matthew Rea
Hamish Watson7Jordi Murphy
Viliame Mata8Marcell Coetzee
Mike Willemse16John Andrew
Pierre Schoeman17Jack McGrath
Simon Berghan18Marty Moore
Andrew Davidson19Kieran Treadwell
Jamie Richie20Sean Reidy
Charlie Shiel21Alby Mathewson
Nathan Chamberlain22Ian Madigan
George Taylor23Michael Lowry

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.